The Cartolympics! Let the Games begin :)

Escrito por Tunder4, 29.05.2014 at 17:20

Escrito por Professor Adog, 29.05.2014 at 17:15

Escrito por Tunder4, 29.05.2014 at 17:04

lol, yes, the shitty maps that you clone and fail at editing?
you haven't made a single original map on your own, you are the kind of guy that can only improve what its already provided to him.

The only map that you have made yet that is noteworthy is your Napoleonic map, which i can't tell if you had collaborators to help you (because the map is made under a different name). and even then, outside of france and UK, the map is shit lol, i don't have the proper knowledge of france to see if the borders that u made are real or not.
and lets not forgett that it can be consider a rip-off tik-tok's napoleonic map.

I had no collabs until Tik wanted to use his units instead. Let's not forget Adog UN <-- first place where we have voting, UN M.A.D., Stock Market, etc, Adog LoN or Adog SFA.

yeah the voting system... the one that i had to help you re-do because it was plain shit?

That was one of my first times actually making a map....that's like going to the beta version of a map and saying this map maker will be rubish forever.

Escrito por Professor Adog, 29.05.2014 at 17:18

Escrito por Tunder4, 29.05.2014 at 17:04

lol, yes, the shitty maps that you clone and fail at editing?

Failed at editing? Please. Do explain

i allow everybody to fully clone all my maps, unlike greedy map makers like you and tik-tok <3
you always talked about hell's ggg was bad, and when you clone GGG you never made it get plays unlike Hell, i had to come of the grave to edit GGG and make it good, but now nobody plays it cuz the units "too complex"

Escrito por Tunder4, 29.05.2014 at 17:23

i allow everybody to fully clone all my maps, unlike greedy map makers like you and tik-tok <3
you always talked about hell's ggg was bad, and when you clone GGG you never made it get plays unlike Hell, i had to come of the grave to edit GGG and make it good, but now nobody plays it cuz the units "too complex"

Keep trying to defend that shit map maker, please do. Hell had months mine's only been out for a while... that's like saying your enigma ww2 is rubbish compared to tito's (absolutely horrible) ww2 because tito actually has more plays. And if mine is so bad why do people still host it but not hell's? surely mine is bad

Escrito por SQUARED, 29.05.2014 at 17:24

Escrito por Professor Adog, 29.05.2014 at 17:10

Let's go through how we judge maps:

> Borders - Worth 15 marks in total, tempted has copy and pasted borders, cut them up, cannot apex borders properly, cannot align borders properly, cannot make lakes, can't make rivers. 1/15

> Units - Worth 15 marks. All other, sometimes main attack, and occasionally a transport unit for planes. If I made shit like that I would never hear the end of your incessant SQUARED, but apparently when tempted does it, IT'S AWESOME. In addition, he cannot even make the tanks have tank icons. Also, his units are confusing and highly inconsistent. I give 3/15 for effort.

> Balancing - Worth 15 marks. If you pick Africa you're dead. If you pick Germany, you've essentially won. You whine when austria loses in napoleon try playing africa with 15 income. Oh wait u don't know shit about what you're talking about. 0/15

> Game play - Flags, units pictures, innovation, Worth 5 Marks. I would give 3/5 for that... he has flags and unit pics but 0 innovation.

Total: 0.4/5

Apparently this is better than Ultimate ww2. Keep crying.

You are biased. All of that is your opinion, not the opinion of the vast numbers of people who play it.

But, really, comparing it to Ultimate WWII? Ultimate WWII is the best scenario by far. None of the maps submitted even slightly compare to it. I compared RP to the maps submitted.

Tell me one thing i said which isn't true. This is not being biased, you just can't accept facts.

A vote is the worst idea you democratic idealist. Let's say we get all the maps from at-war. Tempted would win, would Tik-Tok? NO. You're also not understanding the point here, we aren't trying to find the most popular map, but the best map maker. CARTOGRAPHER. NOT THE MAP. We want to see who is the most skilled, and thus should be rewarded. This is not a popularity contest thank-you.

Well, we look at the maps as examples of work obviously we can ONLY judge in the submitted maps.

A popularity contest would be what u described u democratic fuck, "omgg yay let's all vote for tempted". Stfu bitch. All he did was ruin atwar and you know it deep down in there.

That's autism. We're not holding a popularity contest here. Quality =/= Plays.

Can i get one of these puppy trophies pls??plsss i want it plsplsplspls

Escrito por SQUARED, 29.05.2014 at 18:00

Escrito por Professor Adog, 29.05.2014 at 17:50

Well, we look at the maps as examples of work obviously we can ONLY judge in the submitted maps.

You should have made this clearer.

I must say though, I am a little concerned that a maps popularity has no effect on the outcome of this competition. It's all very well making a map with great borders, but if noone plays it, is it really a good map at all?

I'd argue maps like "The Great War" and "The Greater War" are more deserving of the award than Ultimate WWI, for example, simply because they get played, whereas Ultimate WWI does not.

There are intricate works of cartographic art that never get noticed because of the following

1)most atwar players are creatures of routine, and would rather play the trash they played a million times than try something new
2) most atwar players are cultureless bydlos with scant education, content to roll around in the pigsty that is RP and UN slobbering down their mass produced high fructose corn syrup SP
3) most atwar players are autists who can't manage much strategy other than make a big stack and take the cap so they prefer small maps with lots of reinforcements and money

So yeah, I don't take the popularity of the masses as counting for anything.

So, where are the results?

Escrito por Flaming Spaz, 02.06.2014 at 23:55

So, where are the results?

The mods are deciding whether or not to cancel it so wait a bit

Im bored i want the results

I see the trophies been given out but can't find the results. Could someone point me in the right direction?

Escrito por Meester, 29.07.2014 at 04:45

I see the trophies been given out but can't find the results. Could someone point me in the right direction?

Um you deleted my results thread....

Escrito por Professor Adog, 29.07.2014 at 07:34

Escrito por Meester, 29.07.2014 at 04:45

I see the trophies been given out but can't find the results. Could someone point me in the right direction?

Um you deleted my results thread....

OMG. I had you on ignore list in-game did not know it effects website too. I thought that was a spam post of your as the page was empty. Can you remake it?

Escrito por Meester, 29.07.2014 at 08:09

Escrito por Professor Adog, 29.07.2014 at 07:34

Escrito por Meester, 29.07.2014 at 04:45

I see the trophies been given out but can't find the results. Could someone point me in the right direction?

Um you deleted my results thread....

OMG. I had you on ignore list in-game did not know it effects website too. I thought that was a spam post of your as the page was empty. Can you remake it?

Yeah, you were one of the winners....

Escrito por Professor Adog, 29.07.2014 at 08:10

Escrito por Meester, 29.07.2014 at 08:09

Escrito por Professor Adog, 29.07.2014 at 07:34

Escrito por Meester, 29.07.2014 at 04:45

I see the trophies been given out but can't find the results. Could someone point me in the right direction?

Um you deleted my results thread....

OMG. I had you on ignore list in-game did not know it effects website too. I thought that was a spam post of your as the page was empty. Can you remake it?

Yeah, you were one of the winners....

I notice that.